Mc Pheeters Antique Militaria
Home Page About Us Ordering Information Links

 

     

FORT GRIFFIN – FRANK CONRAD SHIPPED MODEL 1874 SHARPS RIFLE – SHIPPED 1877 - IDENTIFIED TO THE HUNTER:  This Model 1874 Sharps Sporting Rifle, serial number 160306, was invoiced at the Sharps Bridgeport, Connecticut factory on July 9, 1877 to Frank Conrad at Fort Griffin, Texas.  Described in the Sharps Company records as being .45 caliber, using a 2 7/8 inch cartridge; with a 30” full octagon barrel, with, double set triggers, open sights, and weighing 15 ¾ pounds, this rifle survives today in the original configuration.  The original letter from Dr. Richard J. Labowskie, present owner of the Sharps Rifle Company business records, documenting the rifle’s description and its shipment to Conrad, accompanies the sale of this rifle.   

The name “R. C. GUIRE” is stamped on the top flat of the barrel between the front and rear sights.  Robert Carter Guire was an early Colorado Territory pioneer and this, his rifle, was found in “relic” condition in a long abandoned and burned cabin in central Colorado by an employee of the US Bureau of Land Management.   

The importance of Ft. Griffin shipped Sharps Rifles and their historical significance was established in recent collector history by Dr. Robert L. Moore.  In his well known article, “Fort Griffin and the Buffalo Sharps” (Robert L. Moore, The American Society of Arms Collectors Bulletin, No. 52 (April 1985), Dr. Moore recorded that a total of 182 Sharps Rifles were shipped to Frank Conrad, and to the partnership of Conrad & Rath at Ft. Griffin, and of that number, he had been able to identify only 25 of these 182 guns that were still known to exist at the time that article was published.  Since that publication, Dr. Labowskie, current owner of the Sharps business records, has adjusted the number of rifles shipped to Conrad to be closer to 170, with approximately 40 of those having been documented and known to exist in modern collections.  

Dr. Moore noted “All of these rifles that I have seen show much use and at times crude alterations.  They are all tired guns and have little or no finish.  The collector has to accept the fact that a Sharps with lots of finish probably never saw the buffalo range.”

The rifle, as it appeared when it was found, had obviously seen much use, and the butt stock and forearm had been consumed during the cabin fire.  The rifle has been restored to a fully functional weapon, true to its original design and purpose.  The butt stock, forearm and butt plate were restored with replacements obtained from the C. Sharps Company in Montana and several of the internal springs were replaced with original, “new old stock” Sharps Company springs.  The barrel, having a slight bend, was sent to Mr. Norman Johnson of Turtle Lake, North Dakota, for straightening.  The balance of the rifle – the barrel, sights, receiver, trigger assembly and lock – are all original to the rifle as it was discovered.  This rifle has been fired since this restoration work was completed and it is fully functional. 

Given the history of this rifle, as to be expected there is no finish remaining on the metal, and the overall appearance of the metal is shown in the accompanying photographs, featuring a naturally aged patina.  None of the components are weak, broken, deformed or otherwise rendered unserviceable.  As stated above, the rifle is fully functional.  The Sharps Company stamp on the top flat of the barrel, the caliber stamp on the top flat at the breech and the cartridge length on the side barrel flat, the patent information on the rear sight base, and Guire’s name stamp on the barrel are all clear and legible.  The bore is in very good, almost excellent, condition with a clear bright surface and very strong rifling, with only minimal light pitting in isolated areas.  The lock and trigger action is crisp and the double set triggers are fully functional.  The breech block is tight and locks tightly into place.  The forestock and buttstock are replacements, as described above, are well fitted to the receiver, and have been given an aged finish to blend appropriately with the metal. 

Once the rifle was restored, the new owner embarked on a remarkable journey through history to identify “R.C. GUIRE” and his family, uncovering a captivating story of a Western Frontier family.  Of special note, the family revealed that at least two guns belonging to Robert Guire had descended to his grandsons – a Winchester Model 1885 High Wall Rifle in 32-40, and a muzzle loading double barrel shotgun.  In the same manner as the Guire identified Sharps Rifle, the Winchester Model 1885 Rifle was stamped “R C GUIRE” on the top flat of the barrel, and the family history included the story that this Winchester was known as “grandpa’s sniper rifle”, perhaps referring to Guire’s use of this rifle during his days as a deputy marshal.

A considerable amount of research accompanies this rifle consisting of a complete biography of Robert C. Guire; a timeline that tracks the movements, activities, and relationships of the Guire Family; a complete Guire Family history including census records, period personal correspondence, photographs of Robert and several members of his extended family; first person historical accounts from the areas of Colorado that involved the Guire family, including specific mention and records of the Guire family members; period news accounts of the activities of the Guire family members; and copies of the Dr. Moore “Fort Griffin and the Buffalo Sharps” article and other historical material related to Ft. Griffin - in all, over 80 pages.  This is as complete a package of an artifact from the frontier west and the supporting documentation as I have seen offered in some time. 

With such a small number of Sharps Rifles originally shipped to Conrad at Ft. Griffin, and    an even smaller number surviving in modern collections, the opportunity to own one of    these rifles seldom presents itself.  That this rifle surfaced in 2010 after the man who found the rifle passed away, and only this year, 2011, has been identified as a Ft. Griffin gun, makes this rifle one of the most recent discoveries in this very desirable and historic  collecting field.  $35,000

 

ROBERT CARTER GUIRE 

Robert Carter Guire was born February 1, 1856 in Decatur, Iowa, the first of seven children born to David Caylor Guire (b. 03-22-1833) and Nancie Ann Thorn. 

David Guire and his family, to include young Robert, joined the westward immigrant movement in 1862, settling near Monument, Colorado Territory, in what would become El Paso County, where he filed a homestead and preemption claim consisting of 320 acres.  

David Guire’s brothers – Henry (b. 1835) and Jacob (b. 1839) – and their father, Joseph (b. 1810), either made this trip with David, or made the move at some later date, but the brothers and father were in El Paso County, Colorado Territory by June of 1868 and were reported in the same county in the 1870 United States Census.  

The Guire Clan quickly established itself as one of the keystones of this developing settlement community, with the male members of the family assuming leadership roles in combating the depredations committed by Indians, bandits and addressing such issues as the damage to the crops and livestock by the herds of Texas cattle that passed through the area.  In particular, Robert’s father, David, was well known as a brave and fearless defender of the farms and homesteads in the Monument area from Indian attacks.  In one account he is credited with traveling to Denver to secure arms and ammunition for the settlers in El Paso County.  

With young Robert’s exposure to his father’s stalwart personality it is little wonder that he matured to pursue the many adventures that would fill his life.  Although having gained statehood – and a certain claim to civilization - in 1876, Colorado continued to record a colorful and violent history as a very wild part of the American West for many years to come, and it was in this environment that Robert grew and would go on to make his mark.  

The mid-1870’s would prove to have a substantial affect on Robert’s life.  The family was impacted by the death of his mother and his father’s subsequent marriage to his second wife.  During this same period, the uncle with whom Robert was particularly close – his father’s brother Jacob - had become involved in the serious and deadly Lake County War.  Siding with the “Regulators”, Jacob found himself on the losing side and was forced to leave the area, driven out by the opposition known as “The Committee of Safety”. 

Between 1875 and 1880, the whereabouts of both Robert and Jacob are undocumented, but it is during this period that Robert must have come into possession of this Sharps Rifle.  

What is known is that this particular rifle was shipped to Frank E. Conrad at his Ft. Griffin, Texas store in July of 1877.  The caliber, weight and features of this rifle absolutely define it as a rifle specifically intended to be used by a commercial buffalo hunter. Conrad’s store ledger from 1877 survives today in the collection of well known Sharps Rifle collector Gary Robinson of New York. It is common knowledge in the collecting world that Conrad recorded in his ledgers the serial numbers of the rifles he sold, and the names of the hunters to whom he sold them.  Perhaps Robert Guire’s name appears in Conrad’s ledger, recording the sale of this rifle to the young hunter from Colorado.  It seems unlikely that Guire would have obtained the Sharps in any other circumstance, as this is not the sort of rifle a frontiersman would select for subsistence hunting or self defense – it is simply too heavy and too cumbersome for any contemporary purpose, other than hunting buffalo.  

In the course of this research project, a period cabinet card image was located on the Sharps Collector’s Association website depicting a buffalo hunter that bears a strong resemblance to Robert Guire as he is pictured in a portrait with his wife obtained from his granddaughter.  Not only are the facial characteristics remarkably similar in both photographs, but the size and shape of the hands of both men feature the same long slender fingers.  The hunter in the Sharps Association website image is holding a heavy barreled Sharps Rifle with all of the same characteristics of Guire’s rifle and the cartridges in the hunter’s belt could well be the same .45- 2 7/8 cartridges Guire used in his rifle.  While the identity of the hunter is not known, several people who have viewed both images agree that the similarity of both the men and the rifles is certainly uncanny.  

By 1879 the dwindling number of buffalo on the plains surrounding Ft. Griffin no longer supported the commercial harvest, and for all intent and purposes, the southern herd was gone.  The death knell for the town sounded in 1881 when the army abandoned the post and Conrad moved his store to nearby Albany.  With the departure of the hunters wishing to pursue the remaining buffalo herds further north and with them, the only remaining commercial reason for the town to exist, “The Flats” were soon deserted.

Situated on what was then the edge of the Texas frontier, the town of Fort Griffin and the hunters, store and saloon owners, gamblers, soiled doves and others who inhabited the few buildings or roamed the surrounding plains, left very little evidence of their passing.   Never a large community, the population was relatively transient in nature and does not appear to have left much of a written record in such documents as complete census files, newspaper accounts, a city directory, real estate records, or known family letters as is found in other frontier communities.  Given the nature of the town and that so many of the temporary residents gravitated to that area for no other reason than to hunt the buffalo, or to make their living by catering to the needs of the professional hunters, when that brief period ended there was no reason to stay, and even less reason to record what had happened there.   

So, it is of little surprise that no official record of Robert’s presence in Texas during this period has been found; however the identification of this Sharps Rifle as one shipped to Conrad at Ft. Griffin and bearing Robert’s name is compelling evidence that he was indeed present on the Texas plainsAny other explanation of how Guire acquired this rifle involves the consideration and acceptance of a series of coincidences that would have had to occur in the face of incalculable odds.  The timing of the demise of the southern buffalo herd, the end of the hunt on the Texas plains, and the end of the hey day at Ft. Griffin coincided with the return of Robert to Colorado, where he is recorded at his father’s home on the 1880 United States Census.  

Robert’s return to Colorado began a period of his life that from all appearances indicated he planned to establish himself as his father had, as a settled, productive citizen of the new state, and like his father, a man upon whom his neighbors could depend. 

Robert married in 1882, and in the 1885 Colorado State Census, he is shown living in Las Animas County, Colorado, in the area of Trinidad.  A boom town of wild and wooly proportions, Trinidad of the 1880’s saw the likes of Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday and Bat Masterson among its citizens, and experienced more than its fair share of gun play. 

A currently serving law enforcement officer in Trinidad, Colorado has accumulated a considerable history of the city, county, state and federal law enforcement officers that served Trinidad and the surrounding area.  Providing a fascinating insight into the degree of violence that was visited on the town during the late 19Th and early 20Th Centuries, his research has revealed that during the years 1880 through 1920, 24 law enforcement officers were killed in “stand up” gun fights – that is, face to face confrontations – in Trinidad, and the surrounding County of Las Animas.   

Just as his grandfather, father and uncles had done, Robert answered the calling to stand up for the peace and safety of his community.  Between 1880 and 1887, Robert was sworn in as a deputy marshal.  The family history indicates that he was a Deputy US Marshal, and the family is still in possession of his badge, but unfortunately the badge was not available at the time of this writing to confirm to with which agency Robert took his oath.   

During this same period, a range and cattle war had developed around Trinidad, and in his role as a deputy marshal, Robert pursued a family of rustlers.  In a confrontation, Robert shot and killed the head of the family, initiating a series of threats and attempts on his life and that of his family by members of the slain rustler’s family.  The situation escalated to the point that Robert was forced to leave Colorado, removing his family to Arkansas by way of Texas in 1897.  

Settled in Arkansas, he naturally returned to the family business of farming and raising his family.  In a final twist of irony, after surviving a life time of immigrant travel, Indian attacks, settling a frontier territory rife with county wars and battles with bandits, and venturing into the lands of the Comanche and Kiowa to hunt buffalo, Robert succumbed to a simple farming accident.  While digging a well, a bucket fell on his head and caused his untimely death in 1904 at the age of 48. 

The research into Robert Guire and the entire Guire Clan continues at this time, and the researcher has promised to share any additional information that surfaces with the new owner of this Sharps Rifle. 

 
 

Ordering Instructions

Identified Items  

Firearms

Edged Weapons

Saddles and Horse Equipment

Accoutrements

Collectors Ammunition

Uniforms, Insignia, Hats

Canteens and Mess Gear

Gun tools, Bullet molds and Parts

Field Equipment and Artillery

Original Ordnance Manuals, and Photos 

US Army Medical

Reference Books and Reprints