Mc Pheeters Antique Militaria
Home Page About Us Ordering Information Links

 

     

MODEL 1851 COLT NAVY REVOLVER- “US” MARKED MARTIAL FRAME – CUT DOWN 3” BARREL – VERY NICE OLD IVORY GRIPS – GREAT FRONTIER APPEARANCE:  This Model 1851 Colt Navy Revolver presents a wonderful combination of Colt manufacturing history dating from 1858 through the Civil War, and quite probably use on the Western Frontier where it was owned by someone of substantial means who regularly carried this pistol for personal protection.   

This gun features matching serial numbers throughout, to include the barrel wedge.  According to the Colt production records, this revolver was produced in 1864, however a closer inspection reveals several features that suggest there may be more significance in the full story of the manufacture of this Navy than first meets the eye.   

The left side of the frame is stamped “US”, indicating the frame was originally produced for the series of Colt Navy’s produced for the U.S. Army.  An inspector’s initial, “O”, is present on the trigger guard immediately behind the bow, and on the back strap immediately behind the hammer, both consistent with known inspector stamp locations on US Army Model 1851 Colt Navy’s.  There is also a capital “C” stamped immediately next to the “O” in each location.  As discussed in Swayze’s ’51 COLT NAVIES on page 85, in November of 1861 the Ordnance Department ordered that all arms that were inspected and rejected were to be stamped with a “C” (Condemned).   

As noted above, all of the serial numbers on this pistol match – 175881.  Close inspection of the numbers reveals that on the trigger guard and back strap only – the two components with the inspector’s initials and the “C” condemned stamp - the “1” at the beginning of the various stamped serial numbers all match each other – and the “1” at the end of the serial numbers all match – however the first and last “1” were not struck with the same die.  While both characters are the same format and style, the “1” at the beginning of the number is heavier and bolder than the ending “1”, apparently struck with two different stamps, and the “1” at the beginning of the serial number on the back strap seems to be crowded against the edge of the brass, as if it were added after the balance of the number was stamped.   

It is well documented in a number of sources, confirmed by Swayze on the above referenced page, although the US Army might have rejected a component or a complete gun at any point in the inspection process, Colt certainly did not dispose of the condemned piece.  Rather, he regularly used these rejected parts to assemble guns for other customers.  With the demands made by the onset of the Civil War on the arms manufacturing industry, it is understandable that any available components would have been assembled into serviceable pistols for the state militia units or civilian sales, and I believe such is the case with this Colt Navy.    

The frame, trigger guard, back strap and possibly other components of this Navy were produced in 1858 with the “US” on the frame and the other two pieces inspected, but were for some reason rejected and condemned.  Assuming these parts were stamped with serial numbers at the time of manufacture, absent the leading “1”, the resulting serial number of 75881 falls within the known serial number range (40,000-80,000) of those Colt Navy’s made for the US Army.  The later completion of this revolver in 1864 explains the addition of the leading “1” to the previously rejected parts in order to provide the finished revolver with a unique serial number and one that was in sequence with the current production numbers at the time.  A later style of barrel that was introduced in the 101,000 serial number range was used to complete this pistol, evidenced by the later style barrel address present on the barrel which includes “U.S. AMERICA”, and the contour of the loading notch in the barrel lug.  This barrel is the appropriate barrel for this revolver given the full serial number of 175881.  

In the style that became popular on the post-Civil War Western Frontier, the barrel of this Navy was cut down to just over 3” in length to create an effective, and lethal “belly gun” that could be conveniently concealed at a gaming table, in a dance hall, or while traveling on a stage coach, train or riverboat.  All of the serial numbers, inspector marks and Colt stampings are present and legible, and the cylinder scene though worn is still very legible.  The overall surfaces of the brass furniture is smooth with no obvious signs of heavy wear or abuse, and the surface of the iron has an even aged gray finish with no significant pitting or wear. 

Adding considerably to the flavor of this pistol are the beautifully aged genuine ivory grips.  With the exception of a minor chip missing from the leading lower corner on the left side, the grips have no damage, excessive wear or cracking and have a smooth polished surface with the character of the grain developed in a way that is only possible with age and handling.  The grips have experienced some shrinkage as is typical of this old ivory, receding from the edges of the back strap, but otherwise the fit to the surface of the strap is tight and the grips appear to have been with this pistol for a very long time.  

This is a very attractive Colt Navy that combines some interesting, and not often seen, examples of Colt manufacturing history, and the genuine flavor of the American West that is only found in these unique, modified specimens.  Each of these belly guns is a one-of-a-kind treasure and they are certainly a pleasure to own.  $2250

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Ordering Instructions

Identified Items  

Firearms

Edged Weapons

Saddles and Horse Equipment

Accoutrements

Collectors Ammunition

Uniforms, Insignia, Hats

Canteens and Mess Gear

Gun tools, Bullet molds and Parts

Field Equipment and Artillery

Original Ordnance Manuals, and Photos 

US Army Medical

Reference Books and Reprints