Mc Pheeters Antique Militaria
Home Page About Us Ordering Information Links

 

     

REPRODUCTION COLT MODEL NO. 5 “TEXAS” PATERSON REVOLVER – MANUFACTURED IN 1967 – IN UNFIRED CONDITION:  One of the earliest reproductions of the famous Colt Paterson Revolver, this reproduction of the Colt Model No. 5 Paterson Holster Revolver was manufactured in 1967 by MOFRA, a well known Italian firearms manufacturer.  MOFRA’s introduction of their Paterson Revolver predated the reproductions imported by Navy Arms, and those manufactured by Uberti and Palmetto Arms almost two decades later.   

 

MOFRA chose to reproduce the Paterson No. 5 using its original design - that is without the integral loading lever featured in the later original Patersons and those reproductions produced by the makers who followed MOFRA.  As one reviewer has written, “For shooters who have only handled later loading-lever Paterson reproductions, a MOFRA example feels more archaic and experimental – the way the real Paterson must have felt to 1830’s users.”   

The right side of the frame is stamped with the Italian proof stamp set – the star over shield crest; “PN” for “Polvere Nera”, Italian for Powder Black: and XXIII – the Italian Proof House date code for 1967. 

The bottom flat of the barrel is stamped with the proof crest, and “MOFRA” – the corporate logo for the arms manufacturing company of Mainardi Officina Fabrica Replica Armi.  MOFRA, located in Mainardi, Alamiro Brescia, Italy, was founded in the 1960’s.  In 1971 it became Euromanufacture and in 1980 it was absorbed by Palmetto Arms Company.  The bottom flat of the barrel boss and bottom of the frame alongside the trigger mortise are both stamped with the matching serial number “525”.  The bottom of the grip strap is stamped “MADE IN ITALY”.   

MOFRA initially imported their Patersons into the United States through Replica Arms Inc. of Marietta, Ohio, and many of those Patersons bear the Replica Arms stamp on the one side of the barrel boss.  This one does not bear the Replica Arms stamp, however there is no doubt this pistol was produced in 1967 by MOFRA.  If it was imported by Replica Arms, how or why it escaped being stamped with the Replica Arms information, or if it was imported through a different company, who that importer was, is unknown and probably will never be determined.  Fact is, this is an early MOFRA product made in Italy, and it is here. 

This Paterson presents in almost “like new” and definitely in unfired condition.  It features the original 7 ½” barrel length, and is chambered in .36 caliber. The mechanics function as tight as a watch, with no looseness in the joints between the frame, cylinder and barrel, and the trigger drops down as it should when the hammer is cocked.  The classic stage coach scene is engraved on the cylinder and as with the rest of the revolver, it shows no wear and is fully legible. The original blue finish is intact with only a few minor handling scratches and some slight lines from turning the cylinder - nothing particularly notable for a pistol 59 years old.  

The grips provided in the original production of the MOFRA Patersons were probably the most notable cosmetic flaw in the overall appearance of their reproduction.  The grips were in general terms, light in color – possibly beech or some other soft wood, and mostly devoid of any grain.  Given the effort to recreate the Paterson and the level of success MOFRA attained with the overall presentation of their Paterson Revolver, the choice of a wood other than walnut for the grips was ill advised.  So, it’s not surprising that a previous owner of this revolver chose to replace the light wood grips with simulated ivory grips.  The intricate profile at the top curve of the grip on both sides is well executed, as is the profile down the back strap, the inner frame strap and across the bottom toe strap.  The bottom panels of the grip have the classic “up angle” flats on both sides.  The surfaces are well finished and overall smooth without being polished to a high gloss.  The only notable flaw in the grips is they have a slight amount of play in the internal fit of the center block, resulting in forward and back play or movement of the grips on the frame – perhaps 1/64”, if that much.  It is very slight, but its there and has to be acknowledged for a complete description.  To correct this would be a minimal project involving removing the grips, determining where the void which allows the movement is located and filling it with the proper thickness shim which would tighten up the fit.  I suspect whoever made the grips got to this point, tired of trying to get a perfect fit and declared the job “close enough” and stopped.  A fresh set of eyes and hands could complete the fitting with very little time and effort.   

There are a number of known original Paterson Revolvers fitted with carved ivory grips which have been published, providing examples of the simple line “sea shell” designs with which those original ivory grips were embellished; and these grips could be enhanced with that sort of decoration.  Were I going to keep this Paterson, I would be inclined to slightly age the stark whiteness of the grips with the application of some tea, coffee, or a powdered pigment after experimenting on the internal surfaces of the grips until the right coloration was determined.   

These early MOFRA Paterson Revolvers have been described as “historically important as first wave reproductions” in the replica firearms market, and given their age and very limited availability on the current market, that is not an over statement.  While not the of the value nor having the compelling allure of the original Colt Patersons, these MOFRA Patersons certainly have their place in modern collections, especially an example which presents in this exceptional condition.  It will some time before this opportunity is repeated. (0127) $1500

To see a set of reproduction Paterson Revolver implements listed on this site, click here:

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Ordering Instructions

Identified Items  

Firearms

Edged Weapons

Saddles and Horse Equipment

Accoutrements

Collectors Ammunition

Uniforms, Insignia, Hats

Canteens and Mess Gear

Gun tools, Bullet molds and Parts

Field Equipment and Artillery

Original Ordnance Manuals, and Photos 

US Army Medical

Reference Books and Reprints